Plans and Promises

When I first heard President Obama say, “If you like your health care plan, you’ll be able to keep your health care plan,” I did a double take. Because when a politician begins to say things like that, you’d better take notice, and be on guard. My first thought was, “I’m sorry, what right does he have to say whether I can or can’t keep my health insurance?” Further, “What business is it of his what my health insurance looks like?” But then I began to look into that claim and found that it was not going to be true for a whole lot of people.

So when the news began to break last month that many, many people are not able to keep their health insurance plans, I was not surprised. Because – and this is key – I actually read the what the law said. I didn’t just rely on talking points or media spin; I read the actual law. And I saw that it directed health insurance companies to nix policies that changed after the law was passed (and what policy never changes year to year?). I saw that many Americans’ health insurance plans would be canceled, specifically due to the Affordable Care Act. I read the estimates by government agencies that predicted scores of millions would lose their coverage and be forced into the Obamacare exchanges. It was all right there. I was aghast that so many seemed to not believe it or not care. That was until now.

But since people are now beginning to notice and to speak up, since they are losing the coverage they liked and wished to keep, let us take a look at what the President promised, and what he is saying today. And I dare say that you should be frightened by what you see from the most powerful man in the country.

I must pause here to make an appeal to those who are supporters of the President. Perhaps you voted for him. Perhaps you are a democrat who thinks Mr. Obama is a good leader. Please allow me to ask of you a simple question: Do you have the courage to disagree with him? I ask this because I faced a similar challenge during the Bush years. I was a Bush supporter, who twice voted for him, and generally agreed with him. But there were things he did that I had to have the courage to look at and to say, “No, that’s not right.” Will you look into it? Do you have the courage to speak up and to say, “This is not right”?

“If you like your doctor, you will be able to keep your doctor, period. If you like your health care plan, you’ll be able to keep your health care plan, period. No one will take it away, no matter what.” said President Obama in 2010. Sounds pretty straight forward. Sounds simple to understand. It does not sound ambiguous. In fact, the President repeated this claim so often that he seemed angry that he had to keep saying it, that anyone would be skeptical. And he said this for a reason. Polls showed the vast majority of people liked their health insurance, and it would be reasonable that they would resist a plan that told them up front they would lose their coverage and be forced into a more expensive plan.

Thing is, the President – and the entire administration – knew this wasn’t true. Because, well, it was written into the law. But do you expect a sitting President to ever say to the nation, “I lied to you”? No, what they will do is spin. The lines from the White House now include:
“Oh no, you’re not having your policy cancelled. You’re getting an upgrade!”
“We didn’t cancel your insurance, those mean insurance companies did.”
And probably the worst is what the President himself recently said:
“If you had or have one of these plans before the Affordable Care Act came into law, and you really like that plan, what we said was, you could keep it… if it hasn’t changed since the law’s passed.”

No sir, you didn’t. What you said was, “If you like your health care plan, you will be able to keep your health care plan. Period.”

I won’t discuss here why I think President Obama said what he did, and why his party wrote the law as they did – that is a subject that deserves much more space and a lot of care. But what I will say is what I’ve said many times. Go check things out for yourself, and don’t rely on what the media – or even a President – tells you.